Brennan Blanks Nutley as Old Tappan Rolls into Semis

Photo Credits: RSully Pictures

🧢 Old Tappan 6, Nutley 0 — NJS1G3 Quarterfinals

📅 Date & Location: May 30, 2025 | North Jersey Section 1, Group 3 quarterfinal

Game Summary

Dominant Pitching: Old Tappan’s ace David Brennan delivered a standout performance, tossing a complete-game effort (7 IP), allowing just 3 hits with zero earned runs and striking out 7. His performance earned him the win.
Behind him, Jack Lemonie closed out the game with a perfect inning, preserving the shutout.

Key Moments & Stats

Team	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	R	H	E
Old Tappan	2	0	0	4	0	0	0	6	6	1
Nutley	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	3	1

Old Tappan built the lead early, scoring 2 in the 1st inning and breaking the game open with 4 runs in the 4th.
They finished with 6 hits, one error, and left with a 6–0 advantage; Nutley also committed one error.

Offensive Standouts

Max Garcia: 4 AB, 1 H, 2 RBI — delivered timely hitting to drive in runs.
Anthony Onnembo: 3 AB, 2 H, 1 RBI — strong offensive contribution.
AJ Aiello: 2 AB, 1 H, 2 RBI, plus a stolen base — key multi-run hit.

Nutley’s Effort

Starter Sean Fealey absorbed the loss, surrendering all 6 runs in 3.1 innings (5 hits, 4 earned runs, 3 walks, 3 strikeouts).
Ryan Pessoa replaced him, holding Old Tappan scoreless over the final 2.2 innings, striking out 2 and allowing just 1 hit.

🔍 Bottom Line

Old Tappan’s pitching staff stifled Nutley’s bats all day, while timely offense — led by Garcia, Onnembo, and Aiello — provided enough cushion. Brennan’s commanding performance and the team’s clean execution secured a 6–0 shutout, propelling Old Tappan into the sectional semifinals.

Source Link: https://highschoolsports.nj.com/game/1036411

Athlete's Latest Article

Top performers from Sectional Quarterfinals in New Jersey

May 29, 2025

Baseball: Takeaway, top performers from sectional quarterfinals in North JerseyTOP PERFORMER:► Sophomore David Brennan threw six scoreless innings and freshman Jack Lemonie tossed a scoreless seventh and No. 2 Old Tappan defeated No. 10 Nutley, 6-0. Brennan allowed three hits, one walk and struck out seven, and Lemonie allowed one walk and struck out one for the Golden Knights (18-7). Junior AJ Aiello had a triple, one run and two RBI, and junior Max Garcia had a double and two RBI for Old Tappan, which hosts No. 6 Morris Knolls on June 3.

Old Tappan Cruises Past Demarest as Brennan Picks Up the Win

Apr 29, 2025

On April 29, 2025, the Northern Valley Old Tappan baseball team secured an 8–2 victory over rival Demarest, improving their season record to 11–4. The Golden Knights showcased a balanced offensive attack, scoring in each of the first six innings and accumulating 11 hits. Key contributors included Alex Orecchio, who went 3-for-3 with two runs scored, and Selden Kolkebeck, who drove in three runs, including a home run. Senior outfielder Rocco Pierorazio delivered a standout performance, going 3-for-4 with two RBIs, including a double, and scoring a run. Sophomore pitcher David Brennan delivered a strong performance on the mound, earning the win by pitching four innings, allowing two runs on three hits, with five strikeouts and one walk. He efficiently managed his pitch count, throwing 66 pitches over four innings. Brennan's performance against Demarest highlights his development as a reliable starting pitcher for Old Tappan. His ability to control the game early and provide quality innings has been instrumental in the team's success this season.

Old Tappan Shows Grit But Drops a Close Rival Game

Apr 21, 2025

Old Tappan fell to Pascack Valley in a tough 4-1 loss, despite some strong individual performances and flashes of promise throughout the game. At the plate, Selden Kolkebeck was the standout for Old Tappan, going 2-for-3 and providing a steady presence in the lineup. Caden Yoon added a hit and scored the team’s only run, while Max Garcia and Rocco Pierorazio each chipped in with a single. However, Old Tappan struggled to capitalize with runners on base and managed just five hits on the day. On the mound, Kolkebeck got the start and battled through five innings, giving up four earned runs on seven hits while striking out four. Relievers Kai Ross and Chris Cho each pitched a scoreless inning in relief, holding Pascack Valley in check late in the game. Despite their efforts, Old Tappan couldn’t muster enough offense to rally, ultimately falling short as Pascack Valley’s pitching kept their bats quiet.